If the fruit is not recognized, to determine which species a crop belongs to, surely, in addition to fruit and seeds, at least leaves and flowers are needed.[quote 59][quote 3][quote 60].
There are 5 cultivated species of the genus Cucurbita of which 4 were treated here (Cucurbita pepo, C. maxima, C. moschata, C. argyrosperma), the fifth, Cucurbita ficifolia, can be confused externally with a pumpkin plant and is added here in the table for comparison and determination. For each character, a set must be observed and not a single sample, since for example, Cucurbita pepo can have an intermediate leaf with or equal to a typical one of Cucurbita moschata, they are differentiated in the set of leaves and in turn analyzed together with the rest of the sets of characters, since the set of leaves can resemble that of another species or be intermediate between two of them in a particular group of seeds or plant.[quote 60] The examples will be shown. the "typical" characters of each species, ignoring the real variability in them, variability that means that they are not enough on their own for a reliable determination.
Peduncle. It is the most distinctive character between species and subspecies,[quote 61][quote 62] and the first one used for determination:[quote 53][quote 62].
• - Cucurbita maxima subsp. maxima.
• - C. maxima subsp. maxima immature: Peduncle with circular section.[quote 63][quote 62].
• - C. maxima subsp. maxima mature: Large peduncle with circular section (without ribs)[citation 63][citation 62] and corky surface.[citation 63][citation 61] (Millán (1945[92]) describes the wild subspecies C. maxima subsp. andreana and the peduncle is non-corky, more or less herbaceous or fibrous, and deciduous.).
• - Cucurbita pepo subsp. pepo.
• - C. pepo subsp. pepo immature. Peduncle thick and of very variable length, with ribs at well-marked angles with deep grooves (deeply furrowed[citation 61]), 5 primaries and some of the 5 secondaries can be observed more easily than in C. moschata (typically 5 to 8 seen).[quote 63][quote 62].
• - C. pepo subsp. pepo maturing (left) and almost completely mature (right): Like the immature one. The ribs extend short but abruptly against the fruit. The peduncle is the same size in both photos, the dry parts and the green parts are the same color in both photos, in the first there is more green "marbling" than in the second. The peduncle is hard but it could be cut and the inside remained green at the time of harvest.
• - C. pepo subsp. pepo.
• - Cucurbita moschata.
• - C. immature moschata (left) and mature peduncle (right). At least in this variety the peduncle remained greenish-light and with its trichomes when maturing. At the time of harvest, very hardened, it could not be cut transversely with a kitchen knife. 5 primary ribs at gentle angles[quote 62][quote 63] (some of the 5 secondary ones can be observed), often widely spread (flared) against the fruit when reaching it,[quote 62][quote 63] and very hardened.[quote 63][quote 61].
• - C. moschata.
• - Cucurbita argyrosperma.
• - C. argyrosperma: Immature peduncle (left) and maturing (right), thick and covered by rough corks.[quote 61] "Basically 5-angled, rounded, but not elongated against the fruit when it reaches it or if it does, only slightly."[quote 62].
• - C. argyrosperma.
Trichomes or hairs.[citation 64] Cucurbita maxima: Many[citation 61] trichomes that are soft to the touch on leaves and stem.[4][citation 64] Cucurbita moschata: Soft to the touch,[4] it is the one that has the most hairy appearance[108] due to its soft and long hairs (Loy 2011[citation 64]). Cucurbita argyrosperma is similar to C. moschata but with more widely spaced hairs.[quote 61] Cucurbita pepo: Thorny trichomes and a rough appearance on the leaves and stem[4][quote 64][quote 61] which in some crops can be very irritating.[quote 64].
The trichomes are a more variable character than the peduncle, some varieties can be glabrous and others very hairy, the peduncles with long hairs are C. moschata, the spiny trichomes are from C. pepo.
• - Trichomes.
• - Cucurbita maxima: Many short trichomes, they can be soft or more setaceous.
• - Cucurbita moschata: Many trichomes that are soft to the touch and long.
• - Cucurbita pepo: Very characteristically few, prickly trichomes.
Leaves. Pentapalmate, the 5 primary veins may end in rounded or acute lobes, or not.[citation 65].
Cucurbita maxima: orbicular, reniform or trilobed ([110] cited in[111]). Usually not lobed,[4] more or less rounded,[4][citation 61] not indented.[citation 61].
• - Sheet of C. maxima.
• - Cucurbita maxima: Reniform leaf.
• - Cucurbita maxima: Reniform leaf.
• - Cucurbita maxima: Orbicular leaf.
• - Cucurbita maxima: Trilobed leaf.
• - Cucurbita maxima: Trilobed leaf.
• - Cucurbita maxima: Leaf.
Cucurbita moschata: Leaves more or less rounded to moderately lobed (Robinson and Decker-Walters 1997[4]), leaves sharply pentagonal (HS Paris and DN Maynard 2008[citation 61]). Cucurbita argyrosperma: Moderately lobed (Robinson and Decker-Walters 1997[4]), similar to C. moschata in that they are also acutely pentagonal.[quote 61].
• - Sheet of C. moschata and C. argyrosperma.
• - Cucurbita moschata: Leaves.
• - Cucurbita moschata: Leaf.
• - Cucurbita moschata: Leaf.
• - Cucurbita moschata: Leaf.
• - Cucurbita argyrosperma: Leaves of young plant.
Cucurbita pepo: Palmately lobed,[4] forming a figure of sharp lines (not rounded),[quote 61] often with deeply marked lobes,[4] that is, moderately to deeply indented.[quote 61].
• - Sheet of C. pepo.
• - Deeply dissected leaf, only in C. pepo.
• - Deeply dissected leaf, only in C. pepo.
• - Cucurbita pepo.
• - Cucurbita pepo.
• - Cucurbita pepo.
• - Cucurbita pepo, young plant leaf.
The table to recognize the species is from Robinson and Decker-Walters (1997[4]), table 4.1 p. 75, except specified in quotes from JB Loy (2011[24]) and HS Paris and DN Maynard (2008[citation 61]):.
Below is a more in-depth description of morphology for determination or description of cultures:
10 main beams. The peduncle may have ribs (5 or 10) that in the cross section can be seen to coincide with vascular bundles that can be followed until they are found as the central vein of the sepals (which are 5), or that are also continuous with the central vein of the petals (another 5), so they coincide morphologically with their respective lobes ([66]:261). The "ribs" can be continued with the same appearance in the fruit, as in some crops of Cucurbita pepo.
• - Ribs on peduncle and fruit.
• - Cucurbita pepo, flower. Cross section of the peduncle. There are 5 primary ribs and 5 secondary ribs.
• - Cucurbita pepo "Angolan squash", flower. The 5 primary ribs of the flower peduncle can be traced through their vascular bundles to the lobes of the sepals. In this flower they are also found as ribs in the ovary.
• - The ribs (ribs) in a ribbed fruit (ribbed), which in this case coincide with the 10 "main" vascular bundles. Scheme according to Paris et al. (2007[112]).
• - Ribs in an unripe fruit of Cucurbita pepo 'Striato d'Italia'.
• - Cucurbita pepo "Pumpkin" ribbed type.
In the fruit, the ribs (ribs) that carry the bundles of the sepals are the 5 primary ribs ([66]:261), those that carry the bundles of the petals are the 5 secondary ribs ([66]:261), together they are the 10 main ribs and may not differ in size ([66]:261). Among them there may be more ribs called interstitial ribs, often double, and these can also occur in the absence of the main ribs ([66]:261).
The vascular bundles of sepals and petals can also coincide with furrows, which are therefore the continuations in the fruit of the ribs of the peduncle ([66]:261), the furrows can delimit lobes or lobed crests.
• - Grooves and lobes in the fruit.
• - Cucurbita maxima "lead squash", flower. In this case the peduncle is circular and the vascular bundles that can be followed from the sepals (photo) and petals towards the fruit coincide with the grooves, between the grooves the segments or lobes.
• - Cucurbita maxima "lead squash", ripe, lobed fruit.
• - Lobes (Lobes or scallops) between the grooves that coincide with the 10 main vascular bundles. According to Paris et al. (2007[112]).
• - Lobes or "schnitzels" in the pattypan or Cucurbita pepo Scallop group.
Other topographies of the fruit.
• - Fruits with angular grooves and ridges, grooved fruits.
• - Angular grooves (angular ridges), which form ridges (furrows). According to Paris et al. (2007[112]).
• - Angular ridges and furrows in Cucurbita pepo Acorn.
• - Grooved surface, with grooves. According to Paris et al. (2007[112]).
• - Grooved fruit in Cucurbita pepo 'Connecticut Field'.
In the topography of the fruit you can specify if it has a crown (crown[27][113]), as it is called in Cucurbita maxima var. zapallito,[27] Cucurbita maxima 'Buttercup'[113] where it can also be called button (English), or if the fruit is "turban-shaped" (as it is called in fruits of Cucurbita maxima which are called Turban type). The scar that delimits it, where petals, sepals and staminodes (the hypanthium) were located, is the "ring", and comes from a semi-inferior ovary. The ring and crown only occur in Cucurbita maxima, the other species heal differently. The same plant can produce fruits with larger and smaller rings, whose crown can protrude to a greater or lesser extent, and which may or may not have commercial value, depending on the "market type" (market type[citation 68]) sought. The informal horticultural group "Turbante" is generalized by some authors to add all those that have a crown, such as 'Buttercup' (e.g.[113]).
• - Hypanthian scars (ring, crown).
• - Cucurbita maxima "lead squash" with a ring and a small crown that does not protrude.
• - Cucurbita maxima "lead squash" with a turban-shaped, turban-like shape.
• - The same, immature.
• - Cucurbita maxima Turban squash, used for decoration.
• - Cucurbita maxima 'Buttercup' type, with crown (crown[113] or button).
• - Cucurbita maxima var. zucchini with and without crown. In this variety it is negatively selected because it has no commercial value.
• - Compare with the hypanthian scar in Cucurbita argyrosperma.
• - ...in Cucurbita moschata.
• - ...in Cucurbita pepo.
• - ...in Cucurbita pepo.
It can also have a warted surface (warted, some cultivars may call it warty) or with warts (warts), perhaps the same as the curly texture. It can be wrinkled or wrinkled (wrinkled), different from warty.[citation 69] Warts differ in size and density between cultivars,[109] they have been found in cultivars of Cucurbita pepo,[citation 70] of Cucurbita maxima, and in Cucurbita moschata.[115][citation 71], in the same way wrinkles have been found in Cucurbita pepo,[citation 70] in Cucurbita maxima, and in Cucurbita moschata.[115] "Rough" appears to have been used for grooved surfaces, for surfaces with warts, and for surfaces with wrinkles.
• - Other roughness.
• - Wrinkled surface? (wrinkled).[117].
• - Curly surface, warty or with warts, a lot (heavily warted[113]).
• - Warty or warty surface (warted), moderate amount.
• - Surface with thick warts (heavy warts, some websites may show it as heavily warted which in reality would be "very warty"), small amount.
It may contain corksities ("corky-woody striae"?[108]), cultivars may call it a "written" or "embroidered" surface, corky scars may be thicker or finer. In English netted rind.[quote 69].
• - Corky-woody striae.
• - Corksities in Cucurbita maxima.
• - Cucurbita moschata?
• - Cucurbita pepo? (C. pepo 'Winter Luxury'?).
When the fruit does not contain any accidents (ridges, grooves, gutters, etc.) or texture, it is a fruit with smooth topography, e.g. in Paris et al. (2012[109]) for Cucurbita pepo. This means that a lobed fruit, for example, is not "smooth in topography", although its texture may be, it may not have roughness. The topography can also be found subdivided into topologies (each fruit will have only one, with or without crown) and textures (which can overlap: with or without wrinkles, with or without warts, with or without corks), as in table 10 of Paris et al. (2012[109]) that separates "topography of the fruit on the primary vascular bundles" from "warts".
Layer of waxes. Another contribution to the texture is the layer of waxes covering the bark in a similar way to that of the "white pumpkin" or "Chinese pumpkin" Benincasa hispida, present in some cultigens of C. moschata.[quote 72].
Fruit shape. In pumpkins it is very variable even in the same plant, to market the "market types" (market type[quote 68]) are selected, which makes them appear more uniform. Depending on the cultivar, at the time of flower opening, about 3 to 8 days after flower opening, it is possible to calculate what the shape of the fruit will be when it matures. The shape can be rounded, ovoid, pear-shaped, flattened, elongated, tapering, club-shaped, turbinate (top-shaped), turban (as in those with the more prominent crown of Cucurbita maxima 'Turk's Turban'), etc.
Below is the terminology of the market types for the fruits of Cucurbita pepo as in the Paris classification (1986,[116] Paris 2001[118]) which involves the shape of the fruit in which some accident associated with the topology may be included:[116].
• - Market types in Paris (1986) for Cucurbita pepo.
The fruit shapes of Cucurbita pepo that are identified with market types have been used as a character in a classification of cultivars into cultivar groups by Paris himself (1986[116]) that has since gained acceptance.
Color bands. Longitudinal color bands ("stripes"), which match? the position of the crests. "Interestingly, in fruits with longitudinal bands, the inheritance of the color of the band is independent of the characters of the main zone (longitudinal) and the interstitial zone (Paris 2002[119])" ([66]:261).
(types of bands gallery).
"Marbled" leaves[27] or "spotted"[108][120] (mottled leaves). The spots are located in the bufurcations of the veins on the adaxial surface of the leaf,[108] the color (white or silver)[108] and the shape of the spot vary depending on the species.
• - Marbled or spotted leaves.
• - Cucurbita pepo.
• - Cucurbita moschata.
• - Cucurbita argyrosperma.
• - Cucurbita argyrosperma with marbled leaves, young leaves still without spots.
Other variable characters.
• - Others.
• - Dark spot on the stem from the axil at the node.
• - Sepals with filiform lobes.
• - Sepals with subulate lobes.
• - Tendril with longitudinal bands.
• - Seeds with "the center with small scars or scarifications"?[108].
• - Seeds with? the edge of the open margin?